Right here we go once more. Somebody is attempting to extend the federal chief data officer’s authorities. This time it’s the Workplace of Administration and Finances who, in line with Federal CIO Greg Barbaccia, desires to “make sure you have ultimate decision-making authority over all your agency’s IT acquisitions.” This shall be completed by ensuring that every one company contracts, which shall be supplied by company CIOs, have “appropriate clauses.”
This isn’t the primary time that somebody has tried to extend the authorities — and by inference, the accountability — of CIOs. Let’s take a fast journey down reminiscence lane and assessment a few of these efforts.
The primary actual try was Clinger-Cohen in 1996, which formally established the CIO as a direct report back to the company head and recognized CIO tasks. OMB adopted Clinger-Cohen with implementation steerage. Six years later, the E-Authorities Act of 2002 was designed to assist CIOs train their authorities by creating the federal CIO position and assigned new cybersecurity tasks. In 2014, Congress tried once more to extend the authority of the company CIO with the Federal IT Acquisition Reform Act (FITARA), reiterating lots of the similar tasks as Clinger-Cohen. To make sure the success of FITARA, the Home Committee on Oversight and Reform’s Subcommittee on Authorities Operations, led by the late Rep. Gerry Connolly (D-Va.), created a scorecard to trace FITARA progress and held hearings to carry company CIOs accountable for outcomes.
Over the past 20 years, there have additionally been at the least half a dozen OMB memos, two OMB circulars and several other govt orders designed to extend CIO authority or accountability. Regardless of all these efforts, company CIO authority has remained elusive. Company-level CIOs nonetheless have little management over IT technique and execution inside their organizations, a reality that’s well-known and the supply of this newest effort to empower CIOs.
Whereas I recognize the intent, there’s no proof that Federal CIO Barbaccia’s try to strengthen CIO authorities shall be simpler than previous efforts. Directives, scorecards, metrics and paper authorities haven’t moved the needle. That is no totally different.
I used to be the CIO at two totally different CFO Act businesses for a complete of seven years. Everybody who labored in IT at these businesses was skilled, properly intentioned and centered on delivering on their mission aims. In addition they managed their very own budgets and had been accountable to their management, which converged with my chain of command on the company head or deputy company head. This isn’t a productive escalation level. My solely choice was to attain outcomes by way of affect. My staff and I did, in reality, obtain notable outcomes by way of affect.
We saved the taxpayers many tens of millions of {dollars} and delivered vital providers. On the Environmental Safety Company, my staff rescued a program that had spent numerous money and time constructing the flawed product. We talked to finish customers, carried out agile practices and delivered the appropriate software in file time.
On the Vitality Division, we carried out low-code/no-code platforms, improved service supply to the purpose that others in DOE had been voluntarily turning providers over to my staff, delivered agencywide contracts that saved tons of of tens of millions of {dollars} and provisioned an early AI sandbox.
We had many extra wins at each EPA and DOE and I’m pleased with what we completed. However we additionally left cash and outcomes on the desk as a result of affect and political capital have their limits.
Throughout my tenure, I watched in frustration as a number of groups wasted tens of millions of {dollars} trying to construct workflow administration purposes from scratch when software-as-a-service (SaaS) merchandise that met their wants had been available. I watched as groups all through my group constructed duplicative capabilities as a result of everybody needed to manage their very own providers. I watched us procure a number of SaaS merchandise for a similar want as a result of groups selected to run totally different procurements with totally different necessities when their wants might have been met with one. There weren’t sufficient hours in a day to affect all these actions, and in lots of instances, groups had been satisfied that that they had the one doable reply and had satisfied their management of that as properly.
So, if CIOs can’t train their authorities after years of legal guidelines, memos, circulars and govt orders, what is going to assist CIOs take cost? Cash talks. CIOs want direct management over the company’s whole IT price range.
Previous efforts have, at finest, given CIOs the authority to say “no” — usually with unacceptable political penalties — however little authority to say “yes.” The company CIO has not been capable of set strategic path for your complete company and make sure that the group strikes in that path by way of price range management. Finances authority is the one most vital factor that CIOs want to enhance their effectiveness. There may be clear proof that price range management is efficient within the success of many small company CIOs who management your complete IT price range and punch above their weight delivering outcomes.
The logical end result from price range management could be centralizing all IT assets into the CIO’s direct reporting line. This is able to be much more efficient than easy price range management. Nonetheless, reorganizations are disruptive and would take extra time than transferring price range management to CIOs.
If every company had a deputy secretary for administration who operated because the company chief working officer, that may improve the CIO’s inside affect and construct collaboration amongst CIOs, chief monetary officers, chief human capital officers and different operational leaders. Elevating the federal CIO to be a peer to the OMB deputy administrators for administration and price range would improve the federal CIO’s affect, permitting them to higher assist company CIOs.
But when Congress can solely do one factor to assist company CIOs, give them full authority for company IT budgets. Present CIOs the cash after which they’ll really be held accountable for outcomes.
Ann Dunkin served because the chief data officer on the Environmental Safety Company and the Vitality Division. She at the moment is a distinguished professor of the Apply and distinguished exterior fellow at Georgia Institute of Expertise, an unbiased director of the World Interconnection Group and the CEO of Dunkin World Advisors.
Copyright
© 2026 Federal Information Community. All rights reserved. This web site just isn’t supposed for customers situated inside the European Financial Space.
